Sleepy Milk: A Delicious Bedtime Remedy for Insomnia

Maple Vanilla Sleepy Milk—the best addition to a bedtime snack! Natural insomnia remedy and so yummy.

Warm milk. Just the thought of it kinda makes you want to curl up and climb into bed, huh?

This, is warm milk supreme. My secret sleepy weapon. My ultimate stress-busting, warm-and-fuzzying, snooze-inducing favorite addition to my nighttime routine.

Sweet and caramely, rich and creamy, this milky concoction is sure to become a favorite in your family too once you try it!



Maple Vanilla Sleepy Milk

Makes about 2 1/2 cups; 3-5 servings.

Stir all ingredients together and heat at a low simmer until milk is warm, or as hot and steamy as you’d prefer.

Now, I think it’s probably ideal that you drink just a small amount of sleepy milk—so you don’t overdo it on the fluids and cause yourself to wake up having to go to the bathroom—and that you do it about an hour before bedtime so you can have a chance to pee before you’re actually in bed. I usually stick to only about a half-cup serving, myself. You can save whatever you and your family doesn’t drink up in the fridge to be reheated tomorrow night.

*A note about the gelatin

I recommend the collagen hydrolysate form of gelatin powder in this recipe, because it dissolves so easily in any type of liquid, hot or cold. It doesn’t gel when refrigerated, and doesn’t leave any kind of a film at the top of your cup as the milk cools. This is the kind that comes in the green can, seen here:

I find that with regular gelatin powder (the kind that gels that you use to make jello), it’s difficult to get it to dissolve in milk without overheating and curdling the milk. But, it is possible to make it work, in case this is the kind you already have on hand. This is the one I’m talking about, in the red canister:

To use this type of gelatin, take a half cup of the milk, while still cold, and pour it into a bowl, then sprinkle the spoonful of gelatin over it. Let it sit for a minute or so while the gelatin absorbs the moisture and transforms into something that looks like a little puddle of goo, but feels solid. Then, pour the hot milk mixture over it and stir it in until it dissolves.

Why This Works

It’s not just because of fond childhood memories of warm milk at bedtime that makes this milk so effective at putting you in the mood to snooze. Almost all the ingredients have secret sleepy powers! Check it out.

Nutritious dairy for balanced fats, proteins and carbohydrate

Grass-fed milk is about as perfect a food as it gets. Especially because it’s so perfectly balanced—between all three macronutrients. It’s always good to aim for balance in your meals and snacks, but especially before bedtime.

“A stress-reducing snack will include some carbohydrates, fats and protein. The combination is satisfying and provides the body with the different fuels and rebuilding materials it needs to get through the night without raising stress hormones to make up for what’s missing.”

from The Nourished Metabolism, by Elizabeth Walling

Milk and cream? Definitely fits the bill for this type of stress-reducing bedtime snack.

Calcium to fight insomnia

Grass-fed milk and cream are of course an excellent source of calcium, but did you know that this mineral is excellent for promoting sleep? Calcium is very pro-metabolic, reducing stress and decreasing levels of parathyroid hormone, which has been known to play a role in insomnia.

Coconut oil for a warming metabolic boost

Coconut oil is a metabolism-stoking superfood. It raises body temperature, and also stabilizes blood sugar. All good things for maintaining a good night’s sleep!

Natural sugars for glucose stability

The natural sugars in maple syrup, molasses, and the natural lactose sugar in milk, all help give your body a boost of glucose to help last you through the night without blood sugar crashes. When blood sugar gets too low, adrenaline will spike and seek out glycogen—a form of stored sugar—in the liver. And when that runs out, the stress response kicks into even higher gear, releasing cortisol to break down body tissue into proteins which the liver then has to convert to glucose to raise blood sugar back up to an acceptable level. This is all very stressful and taxing on the body—not to mention it can seriously disrupt your sleep!

To prevent it, and to help maintain blood sugar stability and keep the stress response from being activated in the middle of the night, it’s best to supply yourself with some fuel in the form of glucose before bed. This will help replenish your liver’s glycogen stores and keep things running smoothly.

Molasses for magnesium

Molasses is good for not only a wholesome source of sugar, but also many important vitamins and minerals. And one mineral in particular, is just what you need to get sleepy—magnesium! Molasses is one of best food sources of magnesium out there. Magnesium is a powerful anecdote to stress, and stimulates muscle relaxation. Insomnia is actually a common symptom of magnesium deficiency, so what better time to get an extra boost of the most potent relaxation mineral than at bedtime?

Sea salt for stress-busting

Salt is one of the best nutritional tools for shutting down stress hormones and boosting the metabolism. Your body goes through natural hormonal cycles, called circadian rhythms, in which a little preventative maintenance of stocking up on this important electrolyte can help to avoid sleep-disrupting stress hormone spikes.

“Circadian rhythms are the sequence of hormonal secretions that take place and repeat themselves about every 24 hours, give or take. For example, in a normal guy you should see testosterone and cortisol peaking in the morning, among other hormones. In the evening you would see cortisol bottoming out and melatonin and growth hormone rising. In the middle of the night adrenaline peaks, roughly around that 4am window.”
Eat for Heat, Matt Stone

If you were wondering why you have a tendency to wake up at around 3 or 4 am, this is probably the reason! A nice, salty snack before bed can keep the flow of your hormonal rhythms on a much more even keel. Salt is thermogenic, pro-metabolic, and boosts feel-good chemicals in the body such as oxytocin, while stopping stress hormones from rising.

Gelatin for calming glycine

Gelatin is nature’s most perfect protein. Among its MANY benefits, are that it’s highly effective for promoting healthy sleep. Glycine, the primary amino acid in gelatin, is very pro-thyroid, pro-metabolic, and highly anti-inflammatory. It also stimulates the production of GABA, a calming amino acid, and acts as an inhibitory neurotransmitter which promotes restful sleep. Sign me up!

Want to learn more about getting restful sleep?


Big news! I wrote a whole book about sleep.

Sleepy Milk is an excellent remedy for getting your body ready to doze off at night, but if you really want to address the true causes of your insomnia, you need to do more than mix up a little batch of sugar and salt.

Sleep health is all about regulating blood sugar and balancing hormones—both dependent on metabolic health. That’s where The Sleep Solution comes in. Once you understand why you’re not sleeping as you should, you can take simple steps to change that and reset your body’s biological clock back to a healthy sleep-wake cycle.

If you want to end the midnight wake-ups and sleepless nights for good, and address the root of your sleep problems rather than the symptoms, this book is for you.

Click HERE to check it out.

UPDATE: Get The Sleep Solution for 98% off, this weekend only!

If you want to learn the secrets to getting better sleep, and end your insomnia for good like I did, you could grab a copy of my latest ebook, The Sleep Solution, which has already helped hundreds of sleep-sufferers finally get the rest they need, for $29.95.

OR, you could spend nine dollars more and get 46 more ebooks, 3 online classes, 15 audio seminars, 2 meal plan packages, 2 magazines, and hundreds of dollars in coupons.

You know, take your pick.

The Fall into Health Autumn Sale, with $2,000 worth of healthy living resources for 98% off, is only available for one week, so don’t miss out! I’ve never seen or been a part of a bigger sale ever.

This HUGE sale includes…

  • 47 e-books (many are best-sellers) – $955 value
  • 15 exclusive podcast seminars (from experts like Joel Salatin, Chris Kresser and more) – $45 value
  • 3 online video classes (with over 60+ hours of video tutorials!) – $238 value
  • 2 meal plan packages (for busy real food cooks!) – $223 value
  • 2 magazine subscriptions (real food and Paleo) – $63 value
  • 21 coupons (for your favorite online healthy living retailers) – Over $500 value
  • PLUS, both of my ebooks: The Sleep Solution: End Your Insomnia Naturally and Real Food for Real Life: How to Eat Healthy Without Going Completely Crazy!

Click HERE to get your hands on this crazy deal while you still can.





HURRY—Sale expires at 12:00 AM PST on Monday, November 11th!





PAID ENDORSEMENT DISCLOSURE: I may receive monetary compensation or other types of remuneration for my endorsement, recommendation, testimonial and/or link to any products or services from this blog, including links. I only recommend products I genuinely love, and that I believe would be of value to my readers. Thank you for your support!

MEDICAL DISCLOSURE: Your health is between you and your health care practitioner. Nothing in this blog is intended for the treatment or prevention of disease, nor as a substitute for medical treatment, nor as an alternative to medical advice. Use of recommendations is at the choice and risk of the reader.

21 Responses to Sleepy Milk: A Delicious Bedtime Remedy for Insomnia
  1. I would add to this cocktail of ingredients nutmeg 500 mg. It is good for insomnia. Milk and nutmeg combo are used in traditional Indian medicine for sleep issues. The sweeteners are good for raising low sugars, which can cause insomnia.

  2. Carrie says:

    My kids have been in the habit of making warm milk at bedtime for years… and they add nutmeg! I never thought of drinking it myself but I’m totally trying this recipe, always looking for ways to get more of my GL gelatin in. :-)

  3. Susan says:

    I made this tonight – it was unbelievably delicious. Had to keep myself from drinking the entire batch. Looking forward to a restful night. Thanks for the awesome recipe!

  4. […] sleepy milk recipe – a natural cure for insomnia looks amazing. My kids have been in the habit of making warm milk at bedtime for years, and they […]

  5. I love warm milk! It totally helps me fall asleep :)

    As for the different kinds of gelatin, I didn’t know about the green one. Very handy! *goes to buy one*

  6. Jeff says:

    My mom is way into nutmeg and she uses it on almost everything. I never really understood why. I’m gonna ask her if she mixes it with milk and why if she does. This is very interesting.

  7. JAMES R. says:

    Je vous remercie beaucoup pour le partage de cette recette. Je sais que c’est celui que je vais faire plus chaque nuit.
    Madam, Thank you very much for sharing this recipe. I know it is one that I will be making most every night.

    • ButterBeliever says:

      Vous êtes les bienvenus! J’espère que vous allez adorer. Merci pour tous ceux qui visitent mon site! 😉

  8. Antonio Marks says:

    I have just made it – it was really yummy. Looking forward to more of your recipes. Thanks for this awesome recipe!I think it will help me to get a better sleep tonight.

  9. Judith says:

    I am not able to drink milk, can I use dolomite powder for replacement?

  10. Rachael says:

    This looks both effective AND tasty. I started using your sleepy sand, and I’ve found that it really helps me feel more…put together? Whole? Before going to bed.

    After reading your post above and The Nourished Metabolism, it’s pretty clear I need more gelatin in my life – in a big way. Thank you for sharing this!

  11. […] a lovely recipe for "sleepy milk" here! Sleepy Milk: A Delicious Bedtime Remedy for Insomnia | Butter Believer Yesterday: 7am – 600gs cottage cheese, coffee with gelatine 1pm – 500 mils OJ, coffee with […]

  12. […] Maple Vanilla Sleepy Milk: A Delicious Bedtime Remedy for Insomnia […]

  13. […] my surprise when one of my favorite bloggers, Emily from Butter Believer shared a post for her Sleepy Milk.  I couldn’t wait to try some.  Emily goes into great detail on her blog about why […]

  14. Ishta says:

    Hi….is there any subsitute for gelatin ?? I would love to try this recipe, but we are vegetarians. Plus, should this be ok for a 4 year old ?

    • ButterBeliever says:

      Hi Ishta, sure, you can simply omit the gelatin. There are other beneficial sleep-promoting nutrients besides the gelatin, and it’ll still taste just as good! I don’t see any reason not to give it to children, but it’s your call of course!

  15. Lisa says:

    I’ve made this a few times now. My husband says he always wakes up with a headache the next morning. Any idea what might be causing that?

    • Amanda Ford says:

      A lot of molasses brands contain sulphur (sulfites)–this could produce headaches in many people. Furthermore, sulphur reduces the nutritional benefit of the molasses. So check to see if that is the problem–otherwise, maybe he is getting too much sugar before bedtime, or has an allergy to one of the ingredients (especially milk). Make sure everything’s organic.

  16. […] Sleepy Milk: A Delicious Bedtime Remedy for Insomnia – Butter Believer […]

  17. jodi says:

    Will warming up the milk do anything to the raw milk to make it….err…. not raw? I don’t want to damage my precious raw milk, it’s hard to come by! could I just use organic grass fed milk that’s been pasteurized? or am I going for not heating it up high enough or long enough to damage it?

Leave a Reply

Wanting to leave an <em>phasis on your comment?

Trackback URL